“To Night Owl, From Dogfish”- A Heartwarming Tale of Family, Friendship, and Inclusivity

A Fresh Perspective on LGBTQ+ Representation

What immediately struck me about this book was its refreshingly authentic approach to LGBTQ+ themes in middle-grade literature. Rather than following the common narrative pattern of focusing on struggles with identity, coming out experiences, or confronting discrimination, the story takes a more naturalistic path. It presents gay parents as an integral part of everyday life, treating their relationship with the same depth and normalcy as any other parental relationship. This matter-of-fact portrayal is precisely what makes the book so powerful and groundbreaking – it demonstrates to young readers that families exist in countless wonderful variations, each equally valid and worthy of celebration. The authors skillfully weave this inclusive perspective throughout the narrative without ever turning the story into what some might call an “issue book” or making the characters’ sexuality the central focus. Instead, they create a rich tapestry of family life that resonates with authenticity and warmth, allowing readers to naturally absorb the message that love and family can take many beautiful forms.

“No one’s supposed to tell anyone, “You two shouldn’t love each other.” But maybe, also, no one’s supposed to tell anyone, “You two should love each other. ”
–To Night Owl, From Dogfish.

The Magic of Epistolary Storytelling

The novel’s masterful use of epistolary format, weaving together a tapestry of letters and emails exchanged between the characters, creates an extraordinarily intimate and immersive reading experience. This storytelling approach allows readers to witness the raw, unfiltered thoughts and emotions of the protagonists in real-time. The revelation that each author took responsibility for writing one character’s correspondence explains the remarkably authentic and distinctly individual voices that emerge – Avery and Bett feel like real people sharing their genuine thoughts and feelings rather than fictional constructs. As someone who deeply values character-driven narratives, I found this collaborative writing approach particularly ingenious in its ability to showcase not only the protagonists’ individual personalities but also their gradual personal transformations and the beautifully complex evolution of their relationship. The format captures every subtle shift in tone, every moment of vulnerability, and every milestone in their journey with remarkable clarity and emotional resonance.

Summer Camp Setting: More Than Just a Backdrop

The dual summer camp settings provide an immersive and dynamic environment that brilliantly catalyzes character growth and relationship development. The first camp, CIGI, with its focus on science and technology, creates an atmosphere of structured learning and intellectual discovery, while the traditional camp offers a more conventional outdoor experience filled with recreational activities and team-building exercises. This contrast in settings allows the characters to explore different facets of their personalities and challenge their comfort zones in meaningful ways. As someone who never experienced summer camp culture firsthand, I found these sections particularly captivating and illuminating. The vivid descriptions of camp activities, from science experiments to traditional campfire gatherings, provided both entertainment value and an authentic window into this quintessentially American coming-of-age experience. The camp environments prove to be the perfect backdrop for friendship formation, offering numerous opportunities for shared experiences, personal growth, and the kind of memorable moments that forge lasting bonds between characters.

Adult Characters Done Right

One of the most remarkable aspects of this novel is its nuanced and thoughtful portrayal of adult characters. In my extensive reading experience, particularly within middle-grade literature, adult figures are often relegated to simplified roles – either serving as one-dimensional authority figures or appearing as mere obstacles in the protagonist’s journey. However, this book takes a refreshingly different approach. The supporting adult cast is masterfully developed, from the thoughtful and complex gay dads to Avery’s understanding and supportive mom, and Bett’s vibrant and wisdom-filled Granny (Gaga). Each of these characters emerges as a fully realized individual with their own distinct personalities, motivations, and growth arcs. What makes their portrayal particularly special is how they consistently work together to create and maintain a nurturing, supportive environment for the girls, while still maintaining their own authentic characteristics and occasional conflicts. This careful attention to adult character development adds an extra layer of depth to the story and provides young readers with realistic, positive examples of adult-child relationships.

“Here’s what we have seen: The way one story ends but then starts up again. The way families are made from people who want to be together more than they want to be apart. The way no one can tell you what is or isn’t a family. Well, they can tell you but you don’t have to listen and you shouldn’t listen. You need to only listen to your heart. The way worrying is sometimes about the wrong thing. The way some people are bold and some people are more scared, but once in a while the parts switch. The way you can discover love even when you don’t expect it.” – To NightOwl, From Dogfish.

Educational Elements That Enhance Rather Than Lecture

The “Did You Know” facts thoughtfully woven throughout the narrative serve multiple purposes, enriching the story through both Avery’s meticulous attention to health-related scientific facts and Bett’s enthusiastic knowledge of the animal kingdom. These educational snippets are masterfully integrated into the storytelling, creating natural learning opportunities that emerge organically from the characters’ distinct personalities and interests. Rather than feeling like didactic interruptions, these fascinating tidbits of information flow seamlessly with the narrative, enhancing our understanding of the characters while simultaneously expanding readers’ knowledge. As an adult reader, I found these educational elements particularly delightful – they strike the perfect balance between being intellectually stimulating and age-appropriate, demonstrating how middle-grade literature can successfully incorporate complex concepts while maintaining its accessibility and appeal. The way these facts are presented through the distinct voices of the main characters adds an extra layer of authenticity, making the learning experience feel natural and engaging.

Breaking Cultural Barriers

Reading this as an Asian woman, I found myself deeply reflecting on how this narrative diverges significantly from the traditional stories that shaped my childhood and cultural upbringing. The book’s masterful handling of complex family dynamics, while consistently maintaining an optimistic and lighthearted tone throughout, serves as a brilliant example of how contemporary literature can effectively bridge gaps in cultural understanding and foster meaningful dialogue across different societal perspectives. What particularly stands out is the story’s approach to traditionally sensitive subjects – like menstruation and coming-of-age experiences – which it addresses with remarkable sensitivity and well-placed humor, especially in showcasing how gay fathers thoughtfully and competently navigate conversations that have historically been viewed as exclusively “mother-daughter” territory. This progressive portrayal not only challenges traditional cultural norms but does so in a way that feels natural and authentically heartwarming.

The Universal Language of Family

What makes this book truly special is its profound and heartfelt exploration of the fundamental question of what constitutes a family in today’s diverse world. The deeply moving quote about families being “made from people who want to be together more than they want to be apart” strikes a powerful emotional chord that extends far beyond the pages of the story. This sentiment masterfully captures the essence of chosen family bonds, illustrating how genuine connections and mutual care create the strongest familial ties, regardless of traditional definitions or biological relationships. The universal truth embedded in this message resonates deeply across different cultures, generations, and social contexts, speaking to readers from all walks of life who understand that family is ultimately defined by love, commitment, and the conscious choice to remain united despite life’s challenges.

Final Thoughts

As someone who reads diversely to broaden my perspectives and continuously seeks out literature that challenges conventional narratives, “To Night Owl, From Dogfish” not only exceeded my expectations but completely transformed my understanding of what middle-grade fiction can achieve. It’s not just an LGBTQ+ inclusive book; it’s a masterclass in storytelling that happens to feature LGBTQ+ characters, demonstrating how representation can be both natural and profound. The 5/5 rating I’ve given it reflects not just the exceptional quality of writing and character development, but its remarkable ability to create deep, lasting emotional connections with readers of all ages, backgrounds, and life experiences.

This book stands as compelling evidence that middle-grade literature can tackle complex themes while maintaining a perfect balance of joy and optimism, never losing sight of its core audience while respecting their capacity to engage with meaningful subjects. It’s a powerful reminder that diverse reading isn’t just about checking boxes or meeting quotas – it’s about discovering and embracing stories that help us understand different perspectives, challenge our preconceptions, and celebrate our shared humanity in all its beautiful variations. The authors have created a narrative that speaks to universal truths while honoring individual experiences, proving that great storytelling knows no boundaries.

For anyone seeking a heartwarming story about family, friendship, and the courage to open your heart to new possibilities, this book is an absolute must-read that will leave a lasting impression on your soul. It’s exactly the kind of inclusive literature we need more of in today’s diverse world – stories that normalize different family structures while focusing on the universal experiences that connect us all, told with authenticity, grace, and an unwavering commitment to showing that love, in all its forms, is what truly makes a family. The book serves as a beacon of hope, showing young readers and adults alike that there are countless ways to build meaningful connections and create lasting bonds that transcend traditional expectations.

---

---

---

---